How to Contest a Will in Australia

How to Contest a Will in Australia

Short answer: most will disputes in Australia are family provision claims. Certain people (usually a spouse, partner or child) can ask the Supreme Court to give them more from an estate because the will did not make adequate provision for their proper maintenance and support. Strict time limits apply, and they differ by state.

There is a second, rarer type of challenge: arguing the will itself is invalid. Knowing which one you’re dealing with is the first step, whether you’re thinking about contesting a will or trying to protect your own.

Two ways to challenge a will

Family provision claim Challenge to validity
What you argue The will is valid but unfair to you The will shouldn’t be accepted at all
Typical grounds Inadequate provision for an eligible person Lack of mental capacity, undue influence, fraud or forgery, not signed or witnessed properly
Outcome if successful Court orders a larger share for you An earlier will, or intestacy rules, apply instead
How common [Likely] The large majority of disputes Less common, harder to prove

Who can make a family provision claim?

[Likely] Eligibility is set by each state’s law, but generally includes:

  • A spouse or de facto partner at the time of death
  • Children of any age, including adopted children and, in most states, stepchildren
  • A former spouse in some circumstances
  • Grandchildren or household members who were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased
  • [Likely] In NSW, someone in a close personal relationship with the deceased

Being eligible is not enough. The court asks whether the will made adequate provision for you, considering things like your financial position, your relationship with the deceased, what you contributed, the size of the estate and the claims of others.

Time limits by state

[Likely] Verify against current legislation before publishing.

State / territory Deadline to file
NSW 12 months from date of death
Victoria 6 months from grant of probate
Queensland Notice within 6 months of death; file within 9 months of death
Western Australia 6 months from grant of probate
South Australia 6 months from grant of probate
Tasmania 3 months from grant of probate
ACT 6 months from grant of probate
Northern Territory 12 months from grant of probate

Courts can sometimes allow a late claim, but don’t rely on it. If you’re unsure what a grant of probate is, see What Is Probate in Australia?

How the process usually works

  1. Get legal advice early. Deadlines are short, and many lawyers in this area offer a free first assessment.
  2. Tell the executor. [Likely] Notifying the executor of your intended claim can stop the estate being distributed before you act.
  3. File in the Supreme Court of the relevant state, with affidavits about your circumstances.
  4. Mediation. [Likely] Most claims settle at or before mediation rather than going to a full hearing.
  5. Hearing, if no settlement is reached. The judge decides what, if anything, you receive.

What does contesting a will cost?

[Likely] Legal costs in a defended claim can run to tens of thousands of dollars. Courts often order reasonable costs to be paid from the estate, but not always, and an unsuccessful claimant can be ordered to pay costs. Some firms work on a “no win, no fee” basis. Every dollar spent on lawyers is a dollar the family no longer shares, which is the best argument for preventing disputes in the first place.

Assets a will contest may not reach

[Likely] In most states, a claim can only be made against assets in the estate. That usually excludes:

[Likely] NSW is the main exception: its “notional estate” rules let the court reach some of these assets.

How to make your own will harder to contest

  • Get the formalities right. Signed, dated and witnessed correctly. Start with How to Write a Will in Australia.
  • Record your reasons. A signed statement explaining why someone receives less (for example, they already received help with a house) gives the court context. It won’t block a claim, but it can shape the outcome.
  • Show capacity. If age or illness could raise questions, ask your doctor to note your capacity around the time you sign.
  • Avoid any hint of undue influence. Beneficiaries shouldn’t arrange the lawyer, attend the signing or witness the will.
  • Talk to your family. Surprises at the reading of a will cause more disputes than almost anything else.
  • Keep it current. Update after marriage, separation, new children or grandchildren, or big changes in wealth.

Lifebook Memories lets you record your wishes, the reasons behind them and the story of your life alongside your will, so your family understands your decisions instead of fighting over them.

General information only, not legal advice. Family provision laws and time limits vary by state and change over time; speak to an estate litigation lawyer about your situation before acting.

 

Scroll to Top